|
REPORT ON CARCINOGENS, ELEVENTH EDITION
Alcoholic Beverage Consumption*
-Known to be a human carcinogen First Listed
in the Ninth Report
on Carcinogens
(2000)
-Consumption
of alcoholic beverages is causally related to cancers of the mouth,
pharynx, larynx, and esophagus.
-The exact composition of many beverages is
confidential business information, though many published data define
the organic compounds typically present at low
levels. Several of the components and contaminants identified in
beer, wine, and
spirits are known or suspected human carcinogens, including
acetaldehyde, nitrosamines, aflatoxins, ethyl carbamate (urethane),
asbestos, and arsenic compounds (IARC 1988).
Carcinogenicity
Consumption of alcoholic beverages is
known to be a human
carcinogen based
on sufficient evidence of carcinogenicity in human studies that
indicate a causal relationship between consumption of alcoholic
beverages and cancer.
Studies
indicate that the risk of cancer is most pronounced among smokers
and at the highest levels of consumption.
Consumption of alcoholic beverages is causally
related to cancers of the mouth, pharynx, larynx, and esophagus.
Cohort and case
control studies in a variety of human populations are notable for
their consistency in reporting the presence of moderate to strong
associations with dose-response relationships for these four sites.
Evidence supports a weaker, but possibly causal, relation between
alcoholic beverage consumption and increased risk of cancers of the
liver and breast (Longnecker 1994).
The effect of a given level of alcoholic beverage intake on absolute
risks of cancer of the mouth, pharynx, larynx, and
esophagus is influenced by other factors, especially
smoking. However, smoking does not explain the observed increased
risk of
cancers associated with increased alcoholic beverage consumption (IARC
1988, Longnecker and Enger 1996).
No adequate experimental animal carcinogenicity
studies of
alcoholic beverages have been reported in the
literature. Studies
specifically examining the carcinogenicity of
ethanol in animals have
not yielded results that would suggest that the
ethanol component of
alcoholic beverages is solely responsible for the
increases in cancer
observed in people consuming alcoholic beverages.
Additional Information Relevant to Carcinogenicity
Increased frequencies of chromosomal aberrations,
sister chromatid
exchanges, and aneuploidies have been found in the
peripheral
lymphocytes of alcoholics. Ethanol-free extracts of
some alcoholic
beverages induced sister chromatid exchanges in
human cells in
vitro
and mutations in bacteria (IARC 1988).
The mechanism by which consumption of alcoholic
beverages can
cause cancers in humans is not established.
Properties
Ethanol and water are the main constituents of most
alcoholic beverages. Using a standard measure of most drinks, the
amount of
ethanol consumed is similar for beer, wine, and
spirits (10 to 14 g). Beer, wine, and spirits also contain
volatile and nonvolatile flavor
compounds that originate from raw materials,
fermentation, wooden casks used for maturation, and synthetic
substances added to specially
flavored beverages. The exact composition of many
beverages is
confidential business information, though many
published data define
the organic compounds typically present at low
levels. Several of the
components and contaminants identified in beer,
wine, and spirits are
known or suspected human carcinogens, including
acetaldehyde,
nitrosamines, aflatoxins, ethyl carbamate
(urethane), asbestos, and
arsenic compounds (IARC 1988).
Use
Alcoholic beverages have been made and used by most
societies for thousands of years (IARC 1988). Consumption trends,
including
overall level of alcohol consumption, beverage
choice, age and sex differences, and temporal variations, differ
among and within
societies. In many cultures, alcohol also has been
used in medicine and various pharmaceutical preparations.
Production
All alcoholic beverages are produced by the
fermentation of fruit or other vegetable matter. Most commercial and
home production
involves fermented beverages that are classified,
based on raw materials and production methods used, as beer, wine,
or spirits,
although smaller quantities of other kinds of fermented beverages
(cider, rice wine, palm wine, etc.) also are produced. Beer is
produced by fermentation of malted barley or other cereals with the
addition of
hops. Wine is made from fermented grape juice or
crushed grapes;
fortified wines include additional distilled
spirits. Distilled spirits, so named because of liquid distillation
to increase the alcohol
content after sugar fermentation, originate from sources of starch
or sugar,
including cereals, molasses from sugar beets,
grapes, potatoes, cherries,
plums, and other fruits (IARC 1988). Although
ethanol can be
chemically synthesized from ethylene, alcohol
synthesis for use in
beverages is not employed by the alcoholic beverage
industry because
of the presence of impurities from the synthetic
process.
In 1990, American wine production was 4.5 million
metric tons (10
billion pounds), beer production was 375 million
hectoliters (10 billion
gallons), and spirit production was 18.5 million
hectoliters (490 million
gallons) (ARF 1994). World total production of the
same beverages was
29 million metric tons (6.4 billion pounds) of beer,
1 million hectoliters
(26.4 million gallons) of wine, and 58 million
hectoliters (1.5 billion
gallons) of spirits. In the United States in 2001,
per capita consumption
of beer was 21.7 gallons (82.1 L), of wine was 2.0
gallons (7.6 L), and of
distilled spirits was 1.3 gallons (4.9 L) (USDA
2003). The United States
International Trade Administration (ITA) tracks
import and export data
for various categories of beer, wine, distilled
spirits, and other alcoholic
beverages. In 2002, U.S. domestic exports and
imports of many alcoholic
beverages ranged from millions to billions of liters
(ITA 2003).
Exposure
A downward trend in alcohol consumption occurred in
the United
States and many European countries from the turn of
the twentieth
century until the period between the world wars.
Alcohol consumption
in the United States increased from the 1940s until
the early 1980s, and
then began to decrease steadily. By 1993,
consumption had declined to
the lowest level since 1964. Apparent per capita
consumption expressed
in gallons of pure alcohol per year was 1.6 gallons
in 1940,
approximately 2.2 gallons in 1964 and 1993, and
approximately 2.8
gallons in 1980. Per capita consumption of wine and
beer in the United
States was relatively stable over the period
beginning in the early 1980s
and continuing into the 1990s when overall alcohol
consumption was
falling (Williams
et al.
1995). Most of the decrease
in alcohol
consumption can be attributed to decreased
consumption of spirits. Per
capita consumption of wine was the same in 1993 as
it was in 1977,
while consumption of spirits fell by almost 35% over
the same period.
Per capita consumption of beer decreased from 1981
to 1985,
fluctuated thereafter, and in 1993 was 1% below 1977
consumption
levels (NIAAA 1997). The total number of drinks
consumed in the
United States in 1999 was about 65.5 billion for
beer, 13.7 billion for
wine, and 29.3 billion for distilled spirits.
Underage drinkers (aged 12
to 20) consumed 19.7% of the total, and adult
excessive drinkers (more
than 2 drinks per day) accounted for 46.3%. The
heaviest adult drinkers
(highest 2.5%) consumed 27% of the total (Foster
et al.
2003).
Since 1971, the Substance Abuse and Mental Health
Administration
(SAMHSA 2003) has conducted an annual survey on the
use of illicit drugs, alcohol, and tobacco by the civilian, no
institutionalized
population of the United States aged 12 years old or
older. This survey, now called the National Survey on Drug Use and
Health (formerly called the National Survey on Drug Abuse) reports
prevalence and trends
of alcohol consumption at three levels. These
include current use (at least
one drink in the past 30 days), binge use (five or
more drinks on the
same occasion at least once in the past 30 days),
and heavy use (five or
Introduction
The probability that a resident of the United States
will develop cancer
at some point in his or her lifetime is 1 in 2 for
men and 1 in 3 for
women (ACS 2004). Nearly everyone’s life has been
directly or
indirectly affected by cancer. Most scientists
involved in cancer research
believe that the environment in which we live and
work may be a major
contributor to the development of cancer
(Lichtenstein et
al. 2000). In
this context, the "environment" is anything that
people interact with,
including exposures resulting from lifestyle
choices, such as what we eat,
drink, or smoke; natural and medical radiation,
including exposure to
sunlight; workplace exposures; drugs; socioeconomic
factors that affect
exposures and susceptibility; and substances in air,
water, and soil (OTA
|